Thursday, November 13, 2014

Rose: Powerful or Oppressed?

 Is Rose the most oppressed character in this story, or the most powerful?  (One way to decide your answer is to ask yourself if you admire her, or if you think she is a model for other women.)  Reflect on your answer.


At the beginning of the play, Rose is more oppressed. She is bound to Troy, and she is weakened by her trusting and very loving heart. However, her power grows throughout the play. Each time that Troy betrays her or their relationship, Rose’s strength becomes more clear. At the end of the play, she is the most powerful character: she is the one who tells Troy how it is going to work, he loses the control that she gains. 
I believe that Rose should be admired, but not a model for other woman. It is important to recognize her big heart, strength, and ability to distinguish between right and wrong, but no woman should ever subject herself to what Rose went through. No woman should ever feel powerless, and no man should ever think he can control her. The relationship between Rose and Troy is very clearly dysfunctional and destructive. We should admire Rose when she stands up for herself, but we should learn from her mistakes of giving up her power to a man. 

Friday, October 24, 2014

Lear Reflective

1. Which currently famous actors and actresses would you cast in the following roles, and why?
  • Cordelia: Emma Watson, she is the epitome of innocence. Her previous roles have given her the reputation of a gentle, beautiful person that values honesty, much like Cordelia. 
  • Regan: Scarlett Hannah Byrne, or better known as Draco's girlfriend Pansy Parkinson. She is the perfect mix of evil, down to her core.
  • Edmund: Tom Felton, or Draco Malfoy, would be the perfect Edmund, all he needs is a new hair color. He is already incredible evil and manipulative, but he is also a genius. He knows how to work his enemy, and how to trick everyone. 
  • Albany: Matthew Lewis (perhaps you know him as Neville Longbottom?) is the perfect Albany. They are both genially good people, but struggle standing up for what they know is right. However, they're strength grows throughout the play, and in the end they try their best to be the hero. 
  • The Fool: Alam Rickman, or Severus Snape, is the perfect fool. He is rude and sharp, and he may seem like the villain, but in the end he is the wisest and best-friend. 
2. Which character (out of all of them) do you most admire and why? I admire Cordelia the most. She is a character that I aspire to be more like. When her father offers her a third of his kingdom, she would rather be honest and true to herself and true to her love for her father than lie like her sisters. She values integrity over tangible items. Its hard for most people to say that they would tell the truth in a situation like this, which is why I admire Cordelia's honor so much. 
3. Aristotle believes a proper tragedy will evoke a catharsis in its audience.  Which scene induces catharsis?  Can you explain why?  (It will help to review the long definition of catharsis.) Catharsis is defined as strong emotional release, which is most present when Lear strips down to nothing and runs wildly in the rain. His insanity is caused my a realization that he make a mistake by giving complete power to the two daughters that don't care about him, and by banishing the one daughter that truly loves him. When he takes off his clothing, it could represent the striping of his sanity. His little strip scene is the catharsis of the entire play. We see it building up, his growing madness is represented through the growing storm. There are many instances where foreshadowing hints at Lear's insane fate. In Act I, Scene 5, Lear says "O let me not be mad, not mad, sweet heaven!" (1.5.38). We see this buildup throughout the entire play, so it doest come as much of a surprise to the audience when this catharsis occurs. 
4. When Lear and the Fool are leaving Regan's and headed into the storm, Lear is concerned about going "mad" (crazy or senile).  The storm is a symbol of the brewing madness in Lear's mind.  What aspect of aging frightens you, and what could symbolize it? I am scared of going insane, of forgetting memories, and of being so confused and lost all of the time. I thing of aging somewhat like going back to being a kid. You don't have control of your surroundings anymore, your restricted by both your body's abilities and by the people surrounding you, and you lack some intelligence and common sense. While being a child and being old are very very different, and it is almost useless to compare the two, the only connection I can have with being old is being a kid. I never want to be surrounded by the same confusion that I had sometimes as a child, and I never want to forget my life. 
5. How does reflecting on King Lear (its story and/or particular characters) make you feel "uncomfortably at home"? Everyone has their home-life problems. We all have disagreements with family members and we all have done and said things to our family that we later regret. When Lear asks his daughters to put into words how much they love him, it shocks me because I have never been asked that by my parents, and as a child when I asked my parents that question, they would say something like "to the moon and back an infinity amount of times". I cannot relate to Lear's seriousness in this situation, asking someone to describe their love is like asking someone to not fall asleep while reading the phone book front to back. Sorry, that was a weird metaphor. Anyways, King Lear forces us to recognize and think about our own problems that we would rather keep in a little box tucked away. Therefor, we are uncomfortably at home because we can relate to the story, but we would rather not. 

Thursday, August 28, 2014

Death of Salesman; How do you see yourself in a character?

I believe that I am similar to Biff Loman is several ways. Biff has always lived under extremely high expectations, his father seems him as this perfect machine for success. While my parents don’t expect impossible things from me, I expect extreme success from myself. My standards for myself reflect in everything I do, and I shape my life around these ideals. Both Biff and I are cognitively aware of our situations. Biff spends his entire life trying to escape these expectations from his father, and he eventually move to the west and works on a farm. As dramatic as this sounds, in a way I have been trying to escape myself. Not myself literally, but my standards. Part of me wants to become something important, like a doctor, and to spend my entire life learning and helping others. Another part of me just wants to move to Europe and spend my days WOOFing and playing music on the streets. I see a lot of myself in Biff. He is trapped in a world shaped by his father, and I admire his ability to follow his heart and escape the expectations. However, I don’t want my future to be either one of my extremes. Unlike Biff, I want to find the balance between the too. But the first step is to escape my expectations for myself. 

Timeless Truth

Ray Bradbury uses symbolism to highlight the importance of staying true to yourself and maintaining your identity. He shows the consequences of conformity, and uses imagery to express the difficulties that accompany individualism. Each of the characters in Fahrenheit 451 represent a different danger preventing Montag from being himself and from discovering his own identity. However, there are some people and things in the books and symbolize a positive result of individualism. Bradbury uses various devices to show the importance of being yourself, even when you’re drowning in a world of conformity.
The most important symbol becomes apparent very quickly: books. Books represent individualism. Every fight occurs because of books, they are the center of the novel. At the beginning of the novel, Montag beliefs that books are terrible and must be burned; he is being controlled by conformity. However, after he experience the woman burning herself, and after he meets Clarisse, he changes his mind. The woman who killed herself for her books represents the fatal danger of choosing to be yourself: conformity will burn you and your identity. Clarisse, too, represent the death of individualism. Her death was a result of her being different. Before she died, she told Montag, “I’m afraid of children my own age. They kill each other” (Bradbury 27). This is similar to how teenagers “kill” each others individuality using conformity.
The looming threats of conformity are shown through the hound, the fire, and technology. The technology is the primary danger. It is made is mass, there is no differences between any of the TVs in almost all of the communities homes. Technology is the ultimate destruction of individualization. Next comes fire, which acts upon destroying the general differences. The fire destroyed books, in a sense destroying the books owner’s identity. However the fire doesn’t completely kill the person, it only kills a part of them. The hound is the ultimate danger; it is the one who kills the person. In Montag’s world, it literally kills people, but though symbolism, it only kills their spirit, their personal identity.
While these dangers are often victorious, there are always the occasions that someone survives them. This rare survivor inspires hope for everyone, as Montag says after he sees the woman burn herself, “There must be something in books, things we can imagine, to make a woman stay in a burning house, there must be something there, You don’t stay for nothing” (Bradbury 48). Once he sees the woman who defeated the conformity (yes, she died but she died as herself) he is inspired to fight for himself. Both the burning woman and Clarisse light the spark inside of Montag. Usually that is all we need, someone to inspire us. We all have the drive to be ourselves, but we need someone to light the passion within, we need a push.
The less obvious and important symbols are the ones that show us what happens when we give in to conformity. Montag’s wife, Mildred, is the epitome of the modern housewife. She doesn’t work but spends her days inside the parlor room, watching TV with her “family” (she calls the actors in the show her family). Occasionally she will have some friends over so they can all watch TV together. But they have mindless conversations, and they are completely unaware that anything is wrong, although they are all suicidal. She is the perfect citizen, according to the government. All of the firefighters at the station represent something similar to Mildred; they are perfect citizens. Ignorant and brain-washed into believing that books must be burned, they symbolize those that have given into conformity, and they are comforted by it. Montag recognizes the conformity first in the way all the fireman look, “Had he ever seen a fireman that didn’t have black hair, black brows, a fiery face, and a blue-steel shaved but unshaved look? These men were all mirror images of himself!” (Bradbury 30). In order to conquer conformity, one must first recognize that there is a problem.  

Part #5: Pages 130-158

summary:
The Captain hands Montag the fire hose and instructs him to burn his own house down. Montag does as he is told, and lights his house on fire, along with all of the books. The Captain then informs Montag that he is under arrest, and as he goes to restrain him, he find the small communication chip inside Montag’s ear. He tells Montag that they will find whoever is on the other end the the chip and burn his house down, then arrest him. Aware of the danger he has put Faber in, Montag acts rashly and turns the flame hose on the Captain, killing him. He kills the other firefighters there, and quickly burns the mechanical Hound, a violent killing machine. Montag runs away to Faber’s house. Together, they make a plan. They pack Montag clothes without his scent, and they destroy any marks that Montag made in Faber’s house. They turn on the news long enough to discover that Montag is wanted, and that they are sending a new hound on his trail. Montag quickly leave Faber’s house, and he runs away.
text-to-text connection:
Both Jonas and Montag enter the climax of their stories when they preform a dangerous act that defies the government. Jonas steals his foster-brother, Gabe, in order to protect him from death. Montag kills Captain Beatty, in order to protect his life and Faber’s life. After their act of defiance, both characters begin running. The difference between the two characters is their end goal. Montag wants to stop all the books from being burnt, he wants to save many more lives not just one. Jonas, on the other hand, just wants to save Gabe’s life, he doesn’t want to change the society in which he lives in.
text-to-reader connection:

The mechanical hound sent to find Montag represents the constant threat of conformity, which is always looming over High Schoolers. We are always battling our own mechanical hounds, for some its losing weight, or doing drugs in order to fit in. The burning of Montag’s house and the fight between him and the Captain represents something similar. It is the fight to keep your identity, or more so the success in keeping your identity. Montag chose his books and knowledge rather than the comfort of his home, his sacrifice shows that there is always an exchange. Being yourself means giving up popularity, or perhaps losing the people you thought were your friends. After burning the Captain, Montag justifies his actions (to an extent) by saying, “burn them, or they’ll burn you” (Bradbury 117).

Part #4: Pages 107-130

summary:
The Captain hands Montag the fire hose and instructs him to burn his own house down. Montag does as he is told, and lights his house on fire, along with all of the books. The Captain then informs Montag that he is under arrest, and as he goes to restrain him, he find the small communication chip inside Montag’s ear. He tells Montag that they will find whoever is on the other end the the chip and burn his house down, then arrest him. Aware of the danger he has put Faber in, Montag acts rashly and turns the flame hose on the Captain, killing him. He kills the other firefighters there, and quickly burns the mechanical Hound, a violent killing machine. Montag runs away to Faber’s house. Together, they make a plan. They pack Montag clothes without his scent, and they destroy any marks that Montag made in Faber’s house. They turn on the news long enough to discover that Montag is wanted, and that they are sending a new hound on his trail. Montag quickly leave Faber’s house, and he runs away.
text-to-text connection:
Both Jonas and Montag enter the climax of their stories when they preform a dangerous act that defies the government. Jonas steals his foster-brother, Gabe, in order to protect him from death. Montag kills Captain Beatty, in order to protect his life and Faber’s life. After their act of defiance, both characters begin running. The difference between the two characters is their end goal. Montag wants to stop all the books from being burnt, he wants to save many more lives not just one. Jonas, on the other hand, just wants to save Gabe’s life, he doesn’t want to change the society in which he lives in.
text-to-reader connection:

The mechanical hound sent to find Montag represents the constant threat of conformity, which is always looming over High Schoolers. We are always battling our own mechanical hounds, for some its losing weight, or doing drugs in order to fit in. The burning of Montag’s house and the fight between him and the Captain represents something similar. It is the fight to keep your identity, or more so the success in keeping your identity. Montag chose his books and knowledge rather than the comfort of his home, his sacrifice shows that there is always an exchange. Being yourself means giving up popularity, or perhaps losing the people you thought were your friends. After burning the Captain, Montag justifies his actions (to an extent) by saying, “burn them, or they’ll burn you” (Bradbury 117).

Blog #3: Pages 67-106

summary:
Montag begins to read his books, but finds that its difficult to understand the words and phrases. Momentarily stumped, he remembers an old man he met in a park last year. His name was Faber, he was very kind and made several hints to owning and reading books. Quickly, Montag digs up the mans address and contact information, and he goes to his house. Faber is terrified that Montag has come to burn down his home, but Montag shows him a book hiding in his jacket, and gains Faber’s trust. Faber agrees to help him read the books, but the conversation continues and the two decide to stop the firefighters completely by trying to plant books in their homes then calling an alarm on them. However, first Montag must return to the firehouse to give Captain Beatty a book so he is no longer suspicious. Faber give Montag a small earpiece, which will allow them to communicate constantly. Montag returns home to greet his wife and avoid suspicious actions, but he becomes very upset when his wife’s friends come over because they are so dull and lifeless. He gets very angry and reads the women a poem from a book, blowing his cover. Frustrated, he goes to the firehouse and gives a book to the Captain, then stays long enough for a game of poker. While they are playing, the alarm sounds and they all rush off. However, the house that they must burn is Montag’s, and he learns that his wife sounded the alarm.
text-to-text connection:
The Giver and Fahrenheit 451 are similar because both involve a male lead that turns to an older, wiser man for assistance. In both books, the old helper gives the lead something, like a weapon, that will help in their final mission. Faber gives Montag books, and The Receiver gives Jonas memories. However, while in The Giver, The Receiver asks a father figure to Jonas, while Faber fills the role of friend or mentor in Fahrenheit 451. In both books, the lead character is betrayed by a close friend or family member. Jonas discovers that his father, whose job is to take care of children, is also the one who must kill children when they are not strong enough. This truth changes his life. Montag is betrayed by his wife, who reports him to the firehouse for collecting books, as a result he loses his house and his world changes. Both Jonas’s father and Montag’s wife believe they are doing the right thing by harming others, their actions are in favor of the government and the current system.
text-to-reader connection:
While I have never had my house burnt down as a result of a distrustful friend, I have been betrayed and I understand how Montag feels. The original shock and disbelief that he must of felt when he discovered that his wife turned him in was the worst feeling, and what was left after was a feeling of hollowness and loneliness, a feeling that leaves you wondering if you will ever trust again. The connection that Montag has with Faber is one grown from the seed of a common interest. These are the quickest friendships to develop, but the quickest to burn out. For Montag, it was a relief to find a friend in all of the darkness, a similar feeling to being the new kid that finally finds a friend.

Blog #2: Pages 37-65

summary:
After the woman burns herself with her books, something changes in Montag. He decides that there must be something significant in books, something important, that causes people to kill themselves rather than to live in a world without them. He steals a book fromt the woman’s house, and hides it. He becomes ill, and cannot work for a few days. Captain Beatty comes to Montag’s house to wish him health, and stays long enough to tell Montag the story of how their society came to be. He says that technology, depersonalization, conformity, over-population, and extreme simplification all led to the burning of books. Seemingly innocently, Montag asks the Captain what they would to a fireman if he were to take a book. The Captain informs him that all firemen get the itch to read a book, and they give him 24 hours to burn it or they will do it for him. After the Captain leaves, Montag shows his wife the book he stole, her extreme surprise and terror is only surpassed when he shows her his stash of books, which he has been stealing and hiding for months. He then explains his mission, that he will read all of the books in the next 48 hours, then he will burn them.
text-to-text connection:
While Jonas, from The Giver, always felt a little different from his peers, something inside him changed when he discovered that his community killed infants if they weren’t to par with their high standards. His sudden change leads him to rebel by wanting more memories, much like Montag’s realization leads him to desire more books. Both characters recognize a flaw in their utopian societies, and they strive to find some humanity and comfort in knowledge.
text-to-reader connection:

The woman who burned herself was extremely inspirational, much like the buddhist monk who famously burned himself for his beliefs. Her story teaches us that your individualism is something worth dying for, a belief that is lost in modern conformity. High Schoolers especially are taught to conform or face many threats. Montag’s rebellion also inspires independence, that one small change at a time can result in a catastrophic change of heart. His small act of defiance represented by his library translates to the small things that I do that make me who I am. Those books represent a hope for a better future, they represent the little quirks that everyone has that makes them an individual.

Blog #1: Pages 1-37

summary:
Guy Montag is a firefighter in the future, although the exact year is not given. But instead of destroying fires, his job is to start fires in order to burn books and the houses in which they were hidden. The society in which he lives values conformity not individualism. They believe that thinking is much too difficult and it will only lead to corruption, so their days are filled with mindless conversations with unhappy people wearing masks of joy, and many hours spent watching TV, the actors are often referred to as “family”. Montag’s life is just as dull and basic as the rest of the extremely overpopulated earth’s inhabitants, until he meets Clarisse, his new, strange, young neighbor. She causes him to question his world and the think, they spend minutes everyday simply talking about stuff, and he begins to see the flaws in society. Even his work, which only a few days ago he was so passionate about, seems wrong. But when a woman burns herself with her books, Montag snaps.
text-to-text connection:
The modern society in Fahrenheit 451 is much like the society in The Giver, which is also set in a future America. Both books are about the perfect society, where individualism is replaced by conformity as an attempt to create peace. In Fahrenheit 451, books are taken away and color and stories are removed in The Giver, all in order to “keep peace”. Both of the main characters are male, and both meet someone important that changes the way they view their society. Jonas, the boy in The Giver, meets The Receiver, who gives him memories, which influence him to act out against his community by running away. Montag meets Clarisse, who gives him the gift of talking about thoughts, about anything.
text-to-reader connection:
Montag is the perfect example of a teenager in our modern society: both are struggling with their individuality and identity but hide behind a mask of happiness and conformity. We are both forced to conform in order to survive, we are both forced to swallow our believes. However, there are the few that are brave enough to be themselves, no matter how difficult, much like Montag. His story reminds me that I only get to live this life once, and there’s no point in living under a mask of conformity. Clarisse describes her peers as "all say the same things and nobody says anything different from anyone else" (Bradbury 28). Her observations translates to some extent into High School, where conformity is also valued. Being different makes you a target. Clarisse also says that she is ‘afraid of children [her] own age” (Bradbury 27) because they hurt each other, much like modern bullies harm each other. Our society values technology, we believe that it can improve the quality of life. Montag’s world believes this too, their technology is much farther along than ours, but it has the same purpose: to occupy people and to keep them from being curious. The endless hours that Montag’s wife and friends spend in the parlor (or TV) can be compared to the time teens spend with computers or TVs.